homeTeaching Social Psychology


Topic: Social Beliefs and Judgments

 

= new link as of April 1, 2009

Judgment Processes

Thin Slices new
Decision Makingnew
Reading Faces/Emotions
Counterfactual Thinking
Priming
Other Resources new

 

Judgment Errors new

Overconfidence

Schemas and Stereotypes new

Reconstructing Memory

 



 

 

 

 

new Car crash is over before you realize it - Interesting description of the millisecond-by-millisecond events of a side-impact car crash. This particular crash is "over" at 70ms. You aren't consciously aware that you have even been in a crash until 150-300ms. [added 4/19/09]

new "The cognitive neuroscience of eye contact" - [added 4/19/09]

"Out of the ordinary: Finding hidden threats by analyzing unusual behavior" - strategies for identifying important information in intelligence data, from a report from the RAND Corporation [added 12/1/04]

Links to sites concerning bizarre and sometimes dangerous beliefs - Subscriber David Schneider has put together an excellent set of links on cults, paranormal beliefs and other beliefs. [added 7/16/03]]

"Psychology of Intelligence Analysis" - book from the Central Intelligence Agency by Richards J. Heuer, Jr. - the study of thinking applied to intelligence work

Social cognition paper archive - abstracts of articles and links to researchers

Anthony Greenwald - variety of articles/manuscripts from Greenwald

Judgment Processes

Thin Slices

new "Body language can indicate socioeconomic status" - Here is another study indicating how much information we can pick up quickly and nonverbally from brief encounters with others. "The results, reported in Psychological Science, reveal that nonverbal cues can give away a person's SES. Volunteers whose parents were from upper SES backgrounds displayed more disengagement-related behaviors compared to participants from lower SES backgrounds. In addition, when a separate group of observers were shown 60 second clips of the videos, they were able to correctly guess the participants' SES background, based on their body language." [added 4/19/09]

Who's the effective CEO? - Research found that even a very brief exposure to the faces of CEOs permitted participants to distinguish between the "the successful and the not-so-successful CEOs." [added 4/6/08]

Snap judgments and politicians - Very interesting study in which participants saw pictures of two candidates running for the same race for as brief as 1/10 of a second. Participants selected the politician (though participants were not told they were politicians) they thought was more competent. When these ratings were compared with the subsequent outcomes of the political race between the two candidates the researchers found that the snap rating of competence was a very good predictor of who would win the political race. [added 12/11/07]

Decision Making



new "Why we keep falling for financial scams" - a good article in the line of why smart people do dumb things [added 4/19/09]

new Anchoring in credit card rates - Blog entry describing research in which "Hundreds of participants were given a credit-card bill with an outstanding balance of £435.76 and asked how much they could afford to pay off, given their real-life finances. Crucially, half the participants were shown what the minimum compulsory payment was and half weren't. The presence or not of information about a minimum payment didn't affect the proportion of participants who said they'd pay the balance off in full. However, among those 45 per cent of participants who said they'd pay only some of the bill, the presence of information about the minimum required payment had a dramatic effect on how much they said they'd pay." [added 4/19/09]

new "How can decision making be improved?" - This paper reviews the literature to examine strategies for improving decision making [added 4/19/09]

Availability heuristic (Sam Sommers' blog entries) - Sam Sommers has recently begun a series of interesting blogs for Psychology Today, applying social psychology to the world around us. One of his most recent entries is a good one on Michael Phelps and the availability heuristic. Worth a look. Good material for your courses. [added 12/21/08]

"CIA guide to optimised thinking" - "The CIA have released the full text of a book on the psychology of analysing surveillance data. While aimed at the CIA's analysts, it's also a great general guide on how to understand complex situations and avoid our natural cognitive biases in reasoning." [6/20/08]

It's how you present the numbers -- "Would you rather support research for a disease that affects 30,000 Americans a year or one that affects just .01 percent of the U.S. population?" Research on how you present the numbers. [6/20/08]

"Why things cost $19.95" - another interesting recap of recent research from Wray Herbert's APS blog "We're only human" [added 4/6/08]

Representative heuristic - Wikipedia comes through with a good explanation of the concept. [added 3/21/08]

Chocolate's influence on course evaluations! - You heard me. What happens if you are offered chocolate (by a complete stranger, not the instructor) before you complete an evaluation of your instructor? See what the study found. [added 12/9/07]

Risky decision-making - a good report from the 2007 APS convention on risky decision-making across the lifespan [added 11/10/07]

"How do consumers make choices..." - a recent research paper entitled, "How do consumers make choices? A summary of evidence from marketing and psychology" [added 7/8/07]

"I'll agree to do the right thing...next week" - "When making decisions a person often thinks that she should make certain choices (e.g., increasing savings, reduce gas consumption) but does not want to make them. This intrasubjective tension between 'multiple selves' has been referred to as a 'want/should' conflict. In four experiments we show that people are more likely to choose what they believe they should choose when the choice will be implemented in the future rather than implemented immediately, a tendency we refer to as 'future lock-in.'" [added 7/06/07]

When is more better? - interesting article in the APS Observer (2005) about when we perceive more to be better and by how much [added 1/14/06]

Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System - tracks health risk behavior among young people - from the National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion - for example, see recent trends [added 7/19/02]

Jonathan Baron has made a good number of his papers available on the web related to decision-making, and, in particular, maximization of utility (good)

Bounded Rationality - article from ScienceNews (1999) on decision-making heuristics

Reading Faces/Emotions

What does a Bob (or Tim) look like? - very interesting study examining how we associate certain names with certain shaped faces, and how if a name does not match a shape it is easier to forget [added 7/19/07]

Reading faces - article on how Americans and Japanese read faces (and emoticons!) differently [added 7/19/07]

Detection of lying - interesting article in ScienceNews on current research on our ability to detect deception [added 12/1/04]

Counterfactual Thinkingtop

Counterfactual thinking - research site maintained by Neal Roese

"Counterfactual thinking" - (1997) Psychological Bulletin review article by Neal Roese

Priming


A "ripeness bias"? - interesting priming research from the lab of John Bargh [6/20/08]

"Wine labels with animals on them: why they work" - interesting priming research [added 5/20/08]

Primed for spaciousness - A summary of interesting research in which participants were primed for either closeness or spaciousness and then asked to evaluate the aversiveness of different stimuli. Those primed for spaciousness or "distance" from something found the stimuli less aversive. [added 4/26/08]

Priming the unconscious - a New York Times article about the hot area of priming [added 11/10/07]

Media primes stereotypes of "asylum seekers" - This research "draws conclusions about the effects of the media on current public thoughts and behaviours regarding asylum seekers and immigrants entering the UK." [added 12/31/06]

Fear of death and political preferences - A recent article (click here to read original research) has received a lot of attention in our current (2004) U.S. election climate. Research is finding that when we are exposed to reminders of death or 9/11 we tend to favor "charismatic" leaders such as George Bush. It is also another excellent example of the power of priming. The link above is to a summary of this research recently published in the APS Observer. [added 12/1/04]

Other Resources

new Does physical warmth promote interpersonal warmth? - This intriguing study looks at the flipside of cold -- warmth, and looks at how temperature affects perception as opposed to the study above in which perception affects perception of temperature. Fascinating stuff. First link is to the research article; second link is to a blog summary of it. [added 4/19/09]

new Unconscious vs. conscious; powerful vs. powerless - another We're Only Human column reviewing some research finding that those in a more powerful position can better handle conscious processing of complex decisions [added 4/19/09]

"How voters think" - An op-ed columnist uses social judgment research to analyze voters' thinking. [added 4/6/08]

"Do verbal metaphors affect what we see?" - Very interesting set of studies in which the valence of words affects our perception of shades of gray -- positive words produce "lighter" responses and negative words produce "darker" responses. [added 11/21/07]

"How culture affects the way we think" - a good report from the 2007 APS convention [added 11/10/07]

"Unreason's seductive charms" - The link is to a recent (2003) article in the Chronicle of Higher Education in which David Barash examines the appeal of certain irrationalities. Included is an interesting discussion of Leda Cosmides' research on logical reasoning using the Wason Test, comparing abstract versus social situations (e.g., cheating, deception). Further discussion of her research in an evolutionary context can be found at this site: "Evolutionary psychology: A primer". [added 3/23/04]

Common Sense - discussion of common sense, interactive T/F test on some common misperceptions such as "opposites attract" and fallacies leading to "common sense"

Connectionist Models of social reasoning - preface from a book edited by Read and Miller describing connectionist (neural network) models

Apocalyptic Beliefs - PBS Frontline show on the "evolution of apocalyptic belief and how it shaped the western world"

Judgment Errors


new "Why we keep falling for financial scams" - a good article in the line of why smart people do dumb things [added 4/19/09]

new Superstitions - Interesting APS Observer article on superstitious thinking [added 4/19/09]

"Why fondness makes us poor judges, but dislike is spot-on" - Interesting study finds the false consensus effect for items we like, but less false consensus when it is about something we dislike. [added 5/20/08]

Magic and misdirection - interesting article from The New York Times about magicians with a particular interest in the cognitive aspects of their work discussing inattentional blindness and other judgment processes and errors [added 11/10/07]

The Monty Hall Problem - I already have one interactive online illustration of the Monty Hall Problem on the Resources website, but here are two more good, animated illustrations and explanations. The second one is also interactive. Remarkably, the answer still remains the same! [added 7/8/07]

Monty Hall Dilemma - interactive site where students can experience the dilemma and have it explained [added 3/23/04]

Confirmation bias - Paper describes how we selectively gather our news from sources that agree with us. I don't, but apparently most of you do! [added 12/31/06]

Political bias affects brain activity - article from MSNBC [added 2/22/06]

Cognitive biases among professional athletes - A research report from the Social Science Research Network entitled, "It's not about the money: The role of preferences, cognitive biases and heuristics among professional athletes" -- scroll to bottom of page to download/view paper [added 1/11/06]

Forensic "science" - I can't recommend this series enough. This five-part series recently published by the Chicago Tribune does a fantastic job of exposing the lack of scientific support for many forensic techniques such as fingerprinting, arson investigation, and firearm and bite mark identification. It also describes quite well how the justice system and juries so easily fall for the claims of supposed "experts," how they became "experts," and why it is so easy for many of them engage in confirmation bias and belief perseverance. [added 12/1/04]

The forgotten origins of the self-serving bias - Probably like most of you, I assumed that the self-serving bias had been part of human nature for as long as, well, we've been humans. But, with a little digging, I discovered it's a relatively new phenomenon! [added 12/1/04]

Superstitions - a very large collection of superstitions [added 12/1/04]

"What do job interviews really tell us?" - informative essay about snap judgments in an interview setting [added 11/20/03]

Errors in business and diplomacy - more examples of judgment errors and overconfidence from mathematician John Allen Paulos [added 11/11/03]

Power of coincidence - interesting essay from David Myers [added 2/4/03]

Extrasensory perception - also from David Myers, a nice research-based analysis of claims of ESP [added 2/4/03]

The hot hand effect - this blog, from Alan Reifman, is devoted to the phenomenon of the "streaky" shooter/hitter - it includes a description of and links to research and researchers of this possible illusion [added 6/13/02]

"Do we Fear the Right Things?" - essay from David Myers published in the APS Observer on judgment biases related to the events of September 11, 2001

"Mass delusions and hysterias" - description of many such cases over the last millennium - from the Skeptical Enquirer

Overconfidencetop

new "Why we keep falling for financial scams" - a good article in the line of why smart people do dumb things [added 4/19/09]

"The certainty epidemic" - an article on the neurobiology of belief [added 4/26/08]

"The constructive value of overconfidence" - I knew I was right, being overconfident is not all that bad. Told you. [added 4/6/08]

"The danger of knowing for sure" - excellent essay published the day after the recent terrorist attacks by Peter Bowditch that links these events with certainty of beliefs - also includes a nice distinction between skepticism and cynicism

"Why bad beliefs don't die" - interesting essay on why we are biologically designed to be resistant to change - from the Skeptical Enquirer

Schemas and Stereotypes


new Boys with unpopular names more likely to be criminals? - This article describes an interesting study which finds "that adolescent boys with unpopular names are likelier than other boys to be referred to the juvenile-justice system for alleged offenses." The article also describes other interesting research about names. [added 4/19/09]

Humor can perpetuate stereotypes and discrimination - [added 12/16/07]

"Behavior detection officers" - Interesting blog about officials "introduced to US airports who have been trained to pick out potential terrorists by analysing, at least in part, facial expressions." [added 11/10/07]

Media primes stereotypes of "asylum seekers" - This research "draws conclusions about the effects of the media on current public thoughts and behaviours regarding asylum seekers and immigrants entering the UK." [added 12/31/06]

"I can instantly tell whether...blackdar" - an amusing article from the satirical online newspaper The Onion [added 12/31/06]

"Is 'dumb jock' an accurate stereotype?" - The husband and wife team of the excellent blog, "Cognitive Daily," reviews some evidence to answer this question. [added 12/27/06]

Study of violence by former mental health patients - interesting study conducted by the MacArthur Research Network asking "How does the rate of violence by former mental patients compare with the rate of violence by other members of the community?" [added 7/23/03]

Criminal profiling - Swiss Criminal Profiling Scientific Research Site - contains articles, types of profiling, case analyses and more [added 12/2/02]

Two criminal profiling approaches - interesting article (1999) contrasting the two [added 12/2/02]

Find Hidden Bias - the Southern Poverty Law Center has put together an extensive website (Tolerance.org) that includes this series of Implicit Association Tests revealing possible biases towards Arab Muslims, Asian Americans, body image and more - explore the entire site; a lot of interesting examples and material

100 Questions and Answers about Arab-Americans - from the Detroit Free Press - Obviously, stereotyping has been evident since the events of September 11, 2001 - Perhaps sites like this one can help reduce some of our simplistic perceptions

 

Reconstructing Memorytop



Are repressed memories a cultural phenomenon? - This article discusses an investigation of whether reports of repressed memory could even be found in the historical record before 1800. In fact, the researchers posted a $1000 challenge to anyone who could find any such evidence. The article notes that the $1000 was finally awarded to a 1786 account.
[added 4/6/08]

Manipulating images affects memory - [added 3/21/08]

Brain waves distinguish false memories from real ones - [added 12/21/07]

"Recent advances in false memory research" - a good report from the 2007 APS convention [added 11/10/07]

"False beliefs about fattening foods can have healthy consequences" - Here is a popular press story of a recently published article by Loftus and colleagues in which they use a false feedback technique to convince dieters that they don't like strawberry ice cream. [added 1/8/06]

Accuracy of flashbulb memories - report about a recently published article entitled, "President Bush's False Flashbulb Memory of 9/11/01" [added 12/1/04]

False Memory Syndrome Foundation [added 3/23/04]

False memory and brain activity - very interesting finding that accurate recall activates appropriate sensory area in brain but false memories do not [added 3/23/04]

Recovered Memories and "Alien Abductees"
Research press release
Summary of research
Some fascinating research has been conducted recently relating the experiences of people claiming to be alien abductees to the research on recovered memories. The first link above is a press release on that research. The second link is a paper that summarizes some of that research. [added 12/11/02]

Guidelines for Psychologists Addressing Recovered Memories - a publication of the Canadian Psychological Association (1996)

"Innocence Lost: The Plea" - PBS Frontline show on the case of preschool workers in North Carolina accused of child sexual abuse

Eyewitness errors - web site associated with PBS' Frontline show "What Jennifer Saw" - interviews, cases and more

hometop

 

Resources for the Teaching of Social Psychology is a part of the CROW Project, Course Resources on the Web. CROW is sponsored by the Associated Colleges of Illinois and generously supported by UPS. This site was created by Jon Mueller, Professor of Psychology at North Central College, Naperville, IL. Send comments to Jon.